Demotion to Demons

One of many reasons I’m skeptical of religion, or at least of why one religion is better than another, is how political it all seems. The most successful religion in a particular nation or region isn’t necessarily the one that can convince the most people with reasoned debate, but rather the one enforced by the rulers on the people. This might not be so much the case anymore with the rise in separation of church and state, but it’s definitely left its mark. The two most popular religions in the world today remain Christianity and Islam, the ones that historically had the most political force behind them. You could argue that they became dominant because they were true, but if God is really as powerful as people say, couldn’t he find a better way of convincing people than working through emperors and conquerors?

It’s interesting to look at what happens when a society with a particular religion comes to dominate a different one. Back when polytheism was the norm, the conquered cultures would sometimes adopt the gods of their conquerors (after all, they must be better, if they were the victors), or the two would combine in some way. This could happen in peaceful ways as well as violent ones. Nations would adopt the gods of their neighbors, or associate their own gods with other ones, as the Greeks tended to do. As gods could have different aspects, it wasn’t as difficult to reconcile the different religions as it might seem. Monotheism, however, was different by its very nature. If you worship only one god, you’re not going to take kindly to someone trying to make you accept others, or to insist that your almighty deity is simply a manifestation of one of their many gods.

But how did monotheistic cultures view the gods of their pagan neighbors? Now that monotheism is standard in much of the world, it appears that believers think other gods don’t exist at all. As I’ve seen argued before, we’re all atheists when it comes to most gods.

This wasn’t always the case, however. Even the Bible contains indications that the people who wrote it were willing to acknowledge gods other than Yahweh existed, but they weren’t worth worshipping. This looks to have gradually developed into the idea that these others didn’t exist, but the other way of thinking didn’t die out entirely. When Christianity began spreading, it was common for Christians to demonize the gods of other cultures. In other words, their gods were actual beings, but rather than being gods they were demons trying to mislead the people into following the wrong religion. There were indications of this in how Snorri Sturluson treated the old Norse gods.

Demonization was not the only way in which Christians dealt with other religions. Some viewed paganism not as demonic, but as an imperfect preparation for the true faith, which is why there are so many similarities. C.S. Lewis was a more recent adherent to this philosophy, writing in God in the Dock that “the truth first appears in mythical form and then by a long process of condensing or focusing finally becomes incarnate as History.” There was also a process of Christianity borrowing from pagan culture and placing its own traditions on top of existing ones, as seen in the development of Christmas.

This entry was posted in Authors, C.S. Lewis, Christianity, Judaism, Mythology, Religion and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Demotion to Demons

  1. Glenn I says:

    If billions of people (even presently, but especially throughout history) got along perfectly well following the one-true-way that’s not the real one-true-way what makes one one-true-way more real than another one-true-way? … other than maybe force of arms. Which reminds me of the definition of a language: “A dialect with an army.” Perhaps that is what a religion is: “A supernatural belief system with an army.”

    • Nathan says:

      Well, according to some religious beliefs, you’ll have to suffer in the afterlife if you chose the wrong religion, sometimes even if you did this before the right religion even existed.

  2. Pingback: VoVatia

  3. I just came across this interesting article, which postulates the linguistic roots of Hebrew words that English translations of the Bible refer to as “demons” are actually manifestations of a biblical ideology that utilizes mythological references in order to dialog with the surrounding cultures and religions, and yet refute them. In other words, demons in the OT are not what we envision when we hear that term, a vision that comes from Medieval writers, but rather a reference to idols that are ultimately “not gods”:

  4. Pingback: Nine-Tenths of the Law | VoVatia

  5. Pingback: Good Gods and Bad Gods | VoVatia

  6. Pingback: Everybody Poops Genius Pieces | VoVatia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s