Free Ride, Whee Ride, Spree Ride, Glee Ride


The latest issue of The Baum Bugle has an article by David Maxine about Eloise Jarvis McGraw’s writing process for Merry Go Round in Oz, one of the most tightly plotted books in the Oz series. Indeed, it’s so well plotted that it’s kind of surprising there’s a loose end involving the very beginning of the story. At a carnival, Robin Brown encounters a strange carousel barker who talks in rhymes. The man sells Robin a ticket, encouraging him to grab the brass ring for a free ride. When Robin does so, he flies free of the carousel, and indeed of the country, landing in Oz with his merry-go-round steed mysteriously alive.

The brass ring itself turns out to be one of the Circlets of Halidom, which had been stolen by a popinjay. So who is this odd man who sells the ticket? In the article, Eloise is quoted as having said, “I originally intended to explain him somehow or other as an exile or refugee or some such thing the kingdom of Halidom, but I simply forgot to work it in until the book was so tightly set in its present form that I couldn’t find a crack to wedge it into. So I let it remain a dangling end–something I usually would not dream of.” Of course, the Oz books are full of such dangling ends. Absurd coincidence abounds, but especially in Ruth Plumly Thompson’s books there are some elements that just seem TOO fortuitous to be matters of chance, yet are never explained. Why, for instance, would the dummy Humpy in Lost King have looked like Pastoria and had the formula to restore the former king as his serial number? He’s successfully used as a red herring, but I have to suspect there’s more to the story than we find out. Getting back to the barker, I believe Eloise said elsewhere that he was from Roundabout rather than Halidom, which makes more sense in some ways. He’s described as “fat as a butterball, no taller than Robin himself,” while the Roundheads are later said to be “all short and roly-poly.”

Regardless of where he came from, though, how much did he know? He strongly encourages Robin to grab the ring, so he must know it’s going to do something significant, and he doesn’t seem at all surprised when the boy flies off the carousel. Does he know the ring is one of the missing Circlets, and if so why doesn’t he just bring it back himself? It’s also been suggested that he was purposely setting in motion the events that led to Robin being crowned King of Roundabout, but then why did he choose Robin over anyone else? For that matter, why DID the ring bring Robin to Oz and animate the horse? That’s not an ability the Circlet is elsewhere said to have; its official power is to grant skill in handicrafts. The whole thing was presumably magically set up, but did the barker set it up or learn about it some other way? I have to wonder what the original plan was. In the Book of Current Focus discussion, Ruth Berman proposes that the carnival barker might have also consulted the Oracle in the Coracle.

Another interesting thing I found in the article is that illustrator Dick Martin suggested changing a reference to Ozma saying she hadn’t seen the Unicorn of Halidom in 1000 years to simply “ever so long,” claiming that the Oz books never had such specific mentions of periods of time. He was wrong, actually; in Kabumpo Thompson writes that “the little Ruler of Oz has lived almost a thousand years,” and in Wishing Horse she reports that “never in all the thousand years of her young life had this lovely young fairy looked more beautiful.”

While McGraw wrote that her reference was intended “to surprise and amaze” readers, I wouldn’t be too surprised if she was subconsciously remembering one of these two Thompson passages. If they’re taken to be more or less accurate, it raises the question as to how Ozma could still have been a baby when the Wizard of Oz gave her to Mombi. He certainly didn’t arrive from Omaha 1000 years earlier, as it didn’t exist then. Indeed, if Jack Pumpkinhead in his own book is to be believed (perhaps a doubtful proposition), she only lived with Mombi for nine years. I mention this discrepancy here, along with a bit in Magic that suggests Ozma has existed since the beginning of time.


At one point, Maxine mentions that “Sir Greves is written as if he’s deeply in the closet,” with his sneaking around to learn the traditionally feminine art of cooking and ignoring his masculine duties as a knight. There’s quite a bit to say about gender roles in this book, some of which J.L. Bell addresses here. For example, the Unicorn loves Fess despite thinking all other males are too rowdy. It’s also interesting to note, if perhaps not entirely relevant, that Robin’s name is gender-neutral. I’ve met Robins of both sexes in the International Wizard of Oz Club, the female Robin Olderman and the male Robin Hess. In the 1993 Oziana, there’s an excerpt from a book that Onyx Madden (Jim Nitch) was writing that featured a girl named Robin. Robin Olderman was editing it, and said that she was “jealous of the other Robin, the little girl who gets to have a real Ozian adventure.” I have to wonder what happened to the manuscript. Nitch died three years later, but the book was reportedly “in draft stage” when the excerpt was published, so shouldn’t it exist in some form? Speaking of which, Oziana also had a bit of an unfinished sequel to Merry Go Round called “Chapter Three.” If there’s a Chapter Three, there must have been a Chapter One and Two, right? Well, maybe they were stolen by a popinjay, and ended up in the Valley of Lost Things along with Jack Snow’s Over the Rainbow to Oz and the explanation for the weird carnival barker.

This entry was posted in Characters, Dick Martin, Eloise Jarvis McGraw, Gender, Jack Snow, L. Frank Baum, Magic Items, Onyx Madden/Jim Nitch, Oz, Oz Authors, Ruth Plumly Thompson and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Free Ride, Whee Ride, Spree Ride, Glee Ride

  1. Lots of great posts recently, Nathan. I haven’t had time to respond to most, but I’ve enjoyed them! As regards Ozma, and without going into spoilers for Jeff Rester’s upcoming book, I’ll simply state that she remained an infant for years for a very specific purpose. And yes, Pastoria knew her in her prior fairy-form. As to how old she is, I think thousands is correct, as it is for many fairies.

    You also bring up two other points of interest: Jim Nitch (Onyx Madden’s) Jubulut, which I’ve inquired about, and the other extant chapters of McGraws’ sequel story. All I can say is that if anyone comes across either of these, let me know as I’m interested in publishing them.

    • Nathan says:

      If fairies can regenerate into new bodies, that could also explain how Morgan Le Fay could be both a fairy and King Arthur’s half-sister.

  2. Glenn I says:

    Having just finished a reread of Merry-go-round it was fun reading your post on it, the details of the story being fresh in my mind. Once I got the official 40 I was going to read them all in order. But I’d been reading them as I got them so when I managed to get the last missing Oz book rereading the whole series seemed redundant. Finally, a year ago or so I decided to read the RPT books in order – I’d read the Baum books in order as a kid and done it two or three times (if you don’t count the non-Oz fantasies). It was interesting seeing RPT’s work change somewhat over the series and, though most of the books don’t depend on knowledge of previous adventures, it was also instructive to have fresh in the mind the RPT-introduced elements.

    I remember someone saying Merry-go-round was a Thompson book, only really well written. I’m going to agree with that sage. I spotted one mention of a non-Baum-original Oz element – the Cowardly Lion remembers tooling about in a Flyaboutabus. It’s the only instance I can think of after Neill that alluded to Thompson’s Oz.

    • Nathan says:

      I actually haven’t read Merry Go Round all the way through in years, although I did use it for research on the post. As far as references to Thompson goes, MGR also mentions Sir Hokus, who apparently gets his armor from Troth. Not sure why the Yellow Knight would order from a place that specializes in blue armor, but maybe it’s specially made for him. Hidden Valley has the Wizard using wishing pills, and while they were a Baumian creation, it was Thompson who associated them with the Wizard. The visits to Bookville and Icetown are also quite similar to the encounters in Thompson books where the inhabitants of a strange community want to make strangers into beings like them. I believe Rachel Cosgrove claimed she hadn’t read any Thompson books prior to writing Hidden Valley, but maybe she was misremembering.

  3. Pingback: All’s Fair in Oz | VoVatia

  4. Pingback: Rings and Things | VoVatia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s